Mother arrested after 2-year-old found in dumpster

Catrice Sheffield, 28, showed no remorse after incident, police say

PLANTATION, Fla. – A woman was arrested Wednesday by Plantation police after her 2-year-old daughter was found inside a dumpster, police said.

According to an arrest report, a man called 911 and claimed to have seen Catrice Sheffield, 28, throwing her daughter into a blue dumpster in the back of a business in the 1400 block of Northwest Fourth Street.

The man who called 911 said Sheffield was pacing around the dumpster before she "maliciously" threw the child into the dumpster. He said she walked away at a fast pace.

Police said two medical assistants stopped Sheffield and pulled the toddler out of the dumpster.

Sudien Graham told Local 10 News that she was passing by on her way to work when another person called the child in the dumpster to her attention. Graham grabbed the toddler and chased after Sheffield.

"When I ran after her and I yelled to her, she stopped," Graham said. "She did stop and she (broke) down. She (bent) over. You could see that she -- it’s like she reached a breaking point."

Witnesses said they asked Sheffield why she threw her daughter in the dumpster and she said, "I had a miscarriage five months ago and I'm depressed."

The medical assistants said they escorted her inside the building and held her there until police arrived.

According to the report, officers found Sheffield to be disoriented, and it appeared that she was on drugs.

Police said she initially lied and said her name was Katia Wilson, then said it was Yolanda Wilson after a teletype check provided negative results. After the officer told her that she was obstructing the investigation by providing false names, she finally admitted her real name, the report said.

Authorities said the girl didn't appear to have any injuries from the incident, but she was taken to Plantation General Hospital as a precaution.

According to the report, Sheffield denied the witness' version of what happened and said, "Everyone is crazy. I did not throw my daughter in the dumpster. I put her in the dumpster."

Detectives said Sheffield showed no remorse and never asked how her daughter was or who would be caring for her. She also admitted to having a few drinks and smoking marijuana the day before, police said.

Sheffield was arrested on charges of child abuse without great bodily harm and resisting an officer without violence.

"It's just crazy," the girl's father, Kinzell Payne, said. "I don't really have nothing to say about it because it just caught me unexpectedly, and I would have never thought she would (do) anything like this."

An investigator from the Broward Sheriff's Office Child Protective Investigations Section was called to the hospital to determine whether the girl could be placed with family members.


About the Authors

Amanda Batchelor is the Digital Executive Producer for Local10.com.

Recommended Videos