WASHINGTON – Twenty percent of women who attended college during the past four years said they were sexually assaulted, according to a Washington Post-Kaiser Family Foundation poll. But the circle of victims on the nation's campuses is probably even larger.
Many others endured attempted attacks, the poll found, or suspect that someone violated them while they were unable to consent. Some said they were coerced into sex through verbal threats or promises.
In all, the poll found, 25 percent of women and 7 percent of men -- ages 17 to 26 -- said they suffered unwanted sexual incidents in college.
The Post-Kaiser poll, one of the most comprehensive to date on an issue roiling the nation's colleges, provides evidence that sexual assault is often connected to factors woven deeply into campus culture. Most notably, two-thirds of victims say they had been drinking alcohol just before the incidents.
Other potential risk factors, the poll found, are casual romantic encounters known as "hookups" and the presence on campus of fraternities and sororities.
The findings illuminate the difficulty colleges face in preventing violence that is widespread but rarely reported to authorities. Cases that do land on the dean's desk or in the criminal justice system raise what often proves a vexing question: Did both people involved agree to have sex?
The poll yields insights from current and recent students on that issue and others:
- They are torn over sexual consent. Forty-six percent said it's unclear whether sexual activity when both people have not given clear agreement is sexual assault. Forty-seven percent called that scenario sexual assault.
- They do not put sexual assault atop a list of possible concerns about their school. Thirty-seven percent described it as a problem on campus. By contrast, 56 percent viewed alcohol and drug use as a problem.
- They express confidence in how colleges deal with sexual-assault reports. More than two-thirds gave their schools an A or a B for their handling of complaints. Just 8 percent gave their schools a D or an F.
Local 10 News generally does not identify victims of alleged sexual crimes, but The Washington Post interviewed numerous poll participants who chose to be named.
Conducted by telephone from January through March, the poll surveyed a random national sample of 1,053 women and men ages 17 to 26 who were undergraduates at a four-year college — living on campus or nearby — or had been at some point since 2011. They attended more than 500 colleges and universities, public and private, large and small, elite and obscure, located in every state and the District of Columbia.
Reporters also conducted dozens of follow-up interviews with men and women who say they experienced completed, attempted or suspected assaults. Their accounts reveal anguish, fury and confusion about incidents, on and off campus, that haunt a time of discovery and growth. In their first years away from home, while exploring the freedom and opportunity of college life, these students learned the pain of sexual violence.
A 21-year-old at a public university in the Southeast who participated in the poll said she was raped by a male student who escorted her out of a nightclub after she suddenly became woozy and separated from a group of friends. Someone, she suspects, had slipped a drug into her rum drink.
"In the morning, I woke up and my lip was so swollen," the woman said. "I just remember sobbing and sobbing and sobbing the next day. You learn a lot of lessons."
Like most who said they had been assaulted, the woman did not report the incident to university officials or police. She said she worried about whether she would ruin the man's future and wondered what to make of what had happened: Had there been a misunderstanding? Should she have been more vehement in saying no? She remembers clearly crying during the attack. She knew it was rape. But how would others see it?
"Something very wrong happened," she said. "I would never wish what happened to me to happen to anyone."
The poll defined sexual assault to include five types of unwanted contact: forced touching of a sexual nature, oral sex, vaginal sexual intercourse, anal sex and sexual penetration with a finger or object.
After they were read this definition, 5 percent of men and 20 percent of women said they had been sexually assaulted in college. Their assailants used force or threats of force, or they attacked while their victims were incapacitated.
The effect on campuses is even broader. Three in 10 said friends or acquaintances had confided to them in college that they were victims of sexual assault.
Katie MacPherson, 20, a student at Kent State University in Ohio, said she was heading to a concert one evening when a drunk friend attacked her inside a car.
She was in the front passenger seat. Suddenly he lunged forward, MacPherson recalled, grabbed her head and hair violently and tried to kiss her. "Get your hands off me!" she yelled.
The struggle continued until MacPherson managed to open the door and flee. "Immediately I knew," she said. "That was sexual assault."
She didn't report the attack to authorities. But through an intermediary, she told the man's fraternity. "I wanted him to get a wake-up call," she said. "I never expected that from my friend."
HOW BIG IS THE PROBLEM?
College sexual assault, a long-hidden problem, emerged as an issue in the 1980s along with the term "date rape," describing a certain kind of sexual crime involving friends or acquaintances. The date rapist — someone who ignored a "no" or never sought a "yes" — contrasted with the stereotype of the rapist as a predator lurking in the dark.
The issue has gained new urgency in recent years as the number of reports of forcible sex offenses on campus has surged. The Obama administration has opened civil rights investigations of more than 110 colleges and universities for their handling of sexual-violence complaints.
Survivors are pressing colleges for some measure of justice, such as expulsion, even when offenses are not reported to police. Accused students, bewildered by the scrutiny of sexual encounters they thought were consensual, complain that internal inquiries are stacked against them.
Overhanging the debate are questions about the extent of the problem. President Obama, relying in large part on a 2007 federally funded study of students at two unidentified public universities, said last year that "an estimated one in five women has been sexually assaulted during her college years."
Skeptics call that statistic misleading, citing a 2014 study from the federal Bureau of Justice Statistics that found college women were victims of rape or sexual assault at an annual rate of 6.1 per 1,000. Non-students, the BJS said, were raped or sexually assaulted more often than students.
The 2007 and 2014 studies differed significantly in methodology. The earlier survey, by RTI International, asked about specific scenarios of unwanted sexual contact. The BJS study, more focused on crime, asked directly about rape, attempted rape and other sexual attacks. Last year, a blue-ribbon panel said it was "highly likely" the BJS method underestimates victimization.
The Post-Kaiser poll used questions and definitions similar to those in the 2007 study. The poll's margin of sampling error overall was plus or minus 3.5 percentage points. For answers from women or men only, it was five points.
More than two dozen major universities, from Harvard to the University of Southern California, are surveying their own students this year to learn how often sexual assault occurs and what they can do to prevent it. The Massachusetts Institute of Technology last fall said 17 percent of female undergraduates who replied to a survey experienced unwanted sexual behavior at MIT, from touching or kissing to incidents that fit the definition of sexual assault and rape. Researchers reported in May that 19 percent of female freshmen at an upstate New York university said they were raped or victims of attempted rape within a year of starting at school.
The Post-Kaiser poll found that 58 percent of men believe the share of women sexually assaulted at their school is less than 1 in 5. An identical majority of women believe the share assaulted is 1 in 5 or greater.
Students seem less worried about sexual assault than the general public. The poll found 12 percent view it as a big problem at their school. But a separate Kaiser survey in March found 57 percent of the public at large saw college sexual assault as a big problem.
ABOUT THE PROJECT: The Washington Post and the Henry J. Kaiser Family Foundation teamed up to poll more than 1,000 people nationwide who have attended college within the past four years about sexual assault and campus culture. Post reporters then interviewed more than 50 women and men who responded that they had experienced unwanted sexual contact — or attempted or suspected sexual contact — while they were students.
Many students point to another problem: alcohol
Booze, from cheap beer to odd concoctions of liquor and juice, creates major risks. Analysis of the poll found that women who say they sometimes or often drink more than they should are twice as likely to be victims of completed, attempted or suspected sexual assault compared with those who rarely or never do.
A 25-year-old woman recalled a date in her freshman year with a classmate at the University of Pittsburgh. They went to a friend's house. He handed her a drink. It might have been a juiced vodka. A very strong one.
"I woke up the next morning without any pants on," the woman said, "and without any recollection." A few weeks later, she said, the man "made a comment about wanting to see me again and do what he did before. It led me to believe we had some sort of sexual contact."
If so, the woman said, it was without her consent; she was incapacitated.
"I was in no state of mind" to say yes to sex, she said. "The memory is so, so foggy."
A QUESTION OF CONSENT
Another risk factor: hookups. Sixteen percent of women described their dating status during most of college as "hooking up from time to time." They were more likely to report being sexually assaulted or experiencing an attempted or suspected assault than those who were mostly in relationships or those who were not in relationships and not hooking up with anyone.
The poll results suggested that women at colleges with fraternities and sororities were more likely to be assaulted. But statistical analysis found that several other campus characteristics were non-factors. It apparently made little difference whether the school was large or small, public or private, religiously affiliated or described by students as a "party school." Nothing about the race, ethnicity, social class, study habits or religious practices of students predicted whether they would be victims.
Three-fourths of all victims said they told someone about the incident — but only 11 percent told police or college authorities. This finding echoes what experts have long said: Sexual assault is a vastly under reported crime.
Even though 73 percent of those polled said sexual-assault claims are rarely or almost never fabricated, many victims are reluctant to step forward because they fear repercussions. More than 4 in 10 women said it is very or somewhat likely that a woman will be criticized by other students if she reports an assault.
A 19-year-old at the University of Michigan who suspects she was sexually assaulted after she got blackout drunk at a fraternity party explained why she didn't report it to authorities: "I didn't want to start an entire thing. I didn't want that whole frat to have a backlash against me."
She did, however, tell a male friend. His response ended their friendship. He said her suspicion about what happened was wrong: "There's a difference between having drunk, regrettable sex, and being raped," she recalls him saying.
The student's experience underscored one of the most divisive aspects of college sexual assault: The facts of any given incident, especially those left without undergoing an investigation, are often in dispute. That gives rise to speculation about what happened and who was to blame.
The poll found evidence that myths about sexual assault persist among students despite efforts in recent years to dispel them. Six in 10 women said it was a common attitude on their campuses that if a woman is sexually assaulted while drunk she is "at least somewhat responsible." Nearly 6 in 10 women also said it was commonly believed that when women go to parties wearing revealing clothes, they are "asking for trouble."
Slight majorities of men said those attitudes were not common on their campuses.
When posed a hypothetical situation in which they hear that a man is accused of sexually assaulting a woman on campus, about two-thirds of those polled said they generally believe the man is more to blame. About 3 in 10 said both people share blame. Almost none said the woman is more to blame.
A 24-year-old woman who recently graduated from a private university in the Northeast said there were times as a student when she was so drunk that she was unable to consent to sex. She would wake up in bed with someone the next day and say to herself: "What? This is not okay. I didn't agree to this."
But she said the men involved might also have been too drunk. "Whether the other person had the capacity to consent either is something to take into account," she said. "So it's like we're both raping each other."
In the past two years, colleges have begun urgent campaigns to prevent sexual assault. The poll found deep skepticism about some proposals. Seventy-three percent of those at schools with Greek-letter organizations said eliminating fraternities or sororities would have little to no effect. About half of all respondents voiced doubts about the effectiveness of a crackdown on alcohol.
NOVA: What you should know
BARRY: Paint The Campus Teal
ST. THOMAS: The school policy
Instead, 9 in 10 said training students to disrupt potentially harmful situations would be effective — a technique known as bystander intervention. Nearly as many — 85 percent — favored harsher punishments for those found guilty of sexual assault. Colleges have come under fire for leniency toward students they find responsible for sexual assault in disciplinary probes. Federal data show that colleges often reprimand or suspend students in such cases, or order them to undergo counseling, rather than expel them.
Debate has emerged in recent years over whether colleges should be involved in sexual-assault probes at all. Nearly half endorsed the view that as a serious crime, sexual assault should be investigated only by the police. But 83 percent said that if a victim chooses not to go to police but still wants an incident investigated, schools should be required to do so.
There was a gender split on another key question: whether it is more unfair for an innocent person to get kicked out of college after a sexual-assault accusation, or for a person who commits a sexual assault to get away with it.
Men were divided, with 49 percent seeing expulsion of the innocent as the greater injustice and 42 percent taking the other side. But by a decisive 20-point margin, women viewed it as more unfair for an assailant to go unpunished.
Kristina Erickson, 23, said she pursued punishment after her second sexual assault at Beloit College in Wisconsin. The first time, she said, she was "kind of wrestling around" in a dorm with a man she knew when things turned sexual. "I told him to stop," she said. "He thought I was joking. I froze."
Erickson never reported that incident even though she later concluded it was rape. The second time, she said, a drunk man stuck his hand up her skirt in January 2013 as she walked past him in the crowded basement of a fraternity house. She shoved his hand away and yelled at him. Soon after, she filed a complaint with the college. A sanctions letter shows the alleged assailant received a suspension.
Shortly before she graduated, Erickson decided enough was enough. She wanted to push the issue into the open. She wrote an essay for the student newspaper about her experience with sexual assault. It revealed that her mother also had been raped while she was a student at Beloit in the 1980s. "I got a lot of texts, a lot of e-mails," Erickson said. "People contacting me, saying, 'Hey, it happened to me, too.'"
The Washington Post's Nick Anderson reported from Kent, Ohio; Los Angeles; and Washington. Emma Brown, Peyton M. Craighill, Steve Hendrix and Susan Svrluga in Washington contributed to this report.
Follow Local 10 News on Twitter @WPLGLocal10