MIAMI BEACH, Fla. — A Lyft driver spoke Wednesday about what police said was a forced drive from Bay Harbor Islands to Miami Beach, which he believed happened with a gun against his back.

But the most serious charges against the pair accused of putting Atilio Diego Bellanza through the ordeal did not stick.

According to Miami Beach police, officers responded to the 1400 block of Ocean Drive at about 9:14 p.m. Tuesday where Bellanza dropped off the suspects, identified as Ashton Montanez, 22, of Orlando, and Jefferson Mesidor, 25, of Miami.

Bellanza said he picked the two men up near 98th Street and Bay Harbor Terrace. He says on approach, he saw police on scene and two men racing away from them and towards his van.

“One laid down. And the other laid in the back. And they were yelling at me to hurry up,” Bellanza said in Spanish. “He kept touching my face and I told him to stop doing that. And he was screaming and screaming like a crazy person.

“I tried throwing myself from the van multiple times but I could never find the right time. And I thought about what could happen. That maybe they’d shoot me.”

Bellanza said, “A lot of things went through my head. I have kids. That’s why I’m working so much.”

He said when he got out, he took their photos and called 911.

“Thank god this happened to me and not someone else. I have a lot of experience on the street dealing with people. And I took it all very calmly,” Bellanza said. “I think if it were someone else ― if they had been aggressive, they could’ve hurt that person or shot him.“

The two men got out of the car near 1446 Ocean Drive, a three-story property with several tourists and short term rental guests inside. Police found one of the suspects quickly. The other barricaded himself inside, and wasn’t taken into custody until 1 a.m.

Montanez and Mesidor appeared in bond court on Wednesday afternoon after being arrested on kidnapping and resisting arrest charges.

The judge, after reviewing the arrest report, did not find that it contained probable cause for kidnapping.

Even prosecutors believed there was not enough evidence in their arrest forms to support a kidnapping charge.

“If they hired the driver, I don’t know if it’s kidnapping or if it turned into one, if there was a gun,” Judge Mindy Glazer said.

At his bond hearing, Mesidor said he’s on disability.

“I live with my mom, my girlfriend, my brothers and sisters, three dogs and my daughter,” he said.

He wept before his mother spoke to the judge.

“I didn’t sleep last night,” Mesidor’s mother said.

After the most serious charges were dropped, the pair only faced resisting arrest charges and each was being held on a $500 bond as of Wednesday afternoon.

Copyright 2026 by WPLG Local10.com - All rights reserved.