Broward schools superintendent defends her job

School board chair discusses superintendent, general counsel, chief auditor

FORT LAUDERDALE, Fla. – Broward Schools Superintendent Vickie Cartwright has only been on the job since February and she was already having to defend her job on Tuesday.

In her recent 33-page self-evaluation, Cartwright rated herself as ā€œhighly effective.ā€ Six of the nine Broward County School Board members ranked her as ā€œeffective.ā€

The other three members — Gov. Ron DeSantis appointees Manuel Serrano, Kevin Tynan, and Torey Alston — did not submit written evaluations, but Alston, the chair, listed 15 areas of concern and said Cartwright had displayed ā€œfailure of leadership.ā€

In response, the chief of staff sent a 48-page memo to school board members.

ā€œI would encourage the public to read the responses ... because in there you will see a significant amount of work with urgency,ā€ Cartwright said adding she had done the work of two years in three months.

Ultimately, the board decided late Tuesday night to provide Cartwright with a list of problematic areas that they say she must address in writing in the next 90 days.

TUESDAY MEETING

Cartwright delivered a presentation based on the memo. She said there was a need to focus on core academic instruction and the projects needed to improve roofing issues at schools. She was also apologetic.

ā€œThere has been such instability in the past five years of this school district. I wasn’t clear enough to keep rumors calm and I accept responsibility for that,ā€ Cartwright said.

DeSantis said a 2021 grand jury report after the grand jury indicted former Superintendent Robert Runcie and former General Counsel Barbara Myrick required ā€œreformā€ at Broward County Public Schools. But DeSantis’s appointments, except for Alston, have until the Nov. 8 election.

As the school board members were considering the fate of Cartwright, Interim General Counsel Marylin Batista, who replaced Myrick last year, and Chief Auditor Joris Jabouin, Alston said there was a let’s ā€œget to Novemberā€ culture in the school district.

ā€œThese conversations are tough so I apologize to those in the public and members of this board but you must have the tough conversations,ā€ Alston said.

PUBLIC OPINIONS

ā€œIf you believe in the Constitution, allow us to choose our leaders and allow us our freedoms,ā€ Matthew Sparks, an Oakland Park commissioner, said in protest.

Nathalie Lynch-Walsh, the Broward Schools Facilities Task Force chair, was among Cartwright’s critics. She accused her of not building bridges with communities.

ā€œFind a way to put an end to having a bad superintendent before the superintendent becomes worse because that is where this is going,ā€ Lynch-Walsh said.

Shea Ciriago, of the Broward Education Foundation, was among Cartwright’s supporters.

ā€œYou are doing the absolute best that you can,ā€ Ciriago told Cartwright during a recent public meeting.

Bobby Henry, the publisher of the Westside Gazette, warned Cartwright about the nature of the discussions and said, ā€œNow Mrs. Cartwright, it has become personal.ā€

Alston’s list on Cartwright

BCPS (.)

Cartwright’s response


Loading...